Selection is Important

At Tobin Jewelers, we carry hundreds of diamonds - hand-selected for you from Russia and Antwerp, Belgium - which will allow you to easily compare them side-by-side and see the differences for yourself.

Stop in at one of our locations in New Berlin or Mequon to receive a diamond education which will help you determine the diamond for you and your budget.

Price is Key

The Tobin Family (Craig, Mary, Rob, and Steve) travel all over the world to personally hand select the most brilliant diamonds from the world's finest diamond cutters. Since there is no middleman, Tobin Jewelers is able to pass along the savings to you.

Quality is Unsurpassed

We are very picky about the diamonds we select from our exclusive cutters. Even though we purchase many diamonds each year, the majority of the stones we examine are given back to the cutters because they do not meet the standards for Tobin Jewelers.

Almost 60 years and 3 generations later, we continue to raise the bar . . . for you.

Experience is Everything

 It is important because we stand behind our fine jewelry and brilliant diamonds.

When you visit Tobin Jewelers, we encourage you to inspect our diamonds under different lighting conditions using magnification, and to compare multiple loose diamonds side by side so you can see the differences (quality and price) for yourself.

We guarantee a great diamond education and outstanding customer service from the moment you walk through the door of Tobin Jewelers.